During my
first year of residency, I cared for a little girl named Z*. She had been on
the oncology ward for months, fighting an aggressive blood cancer that hadn’t remitted
despite several courses of chemotherapy, each regiment more aggressive than the
last. She was on my patient panel for most of my month of heme/onc, and during
the entire time she was miserable and in incredible amounts of pain. The only
things that seemed to soothe her were sips of water, leg rubs from her mother,
and watching Frozen on repeat. By the time I was caring for Z, her mom had a newborn
and couldn’t spend nights in the room alongside her daughter anymore. I
remember spending a good chunk of my week of night float sitting quietly next
to her, watching Elsa sing ‘Let it Go’ over and over and over again, while she
cried and asked where her mother was.
Z passed
away while I was home one night in between shifts. It was pretty fast - within
a few hours of becoming unstable and being transferred to the ICU, she was
gone. It was the first time I was up close to a child passing away. I had seen
death before, both in medical school and in residency. But I hadn’t seen
suffering- not like this, anyway- in such a young and vulnerable child. It was
completely heartbreaking. Sometimes you reach a point in caring for a patient
when you feel helpless- like your interventions aren’t helping, and maybe by
prolonging suffering they are causing more harm to the patient than good. I
felt like we had failed her- not because she died, but because she was in
terrible pain during much of the end of her life, and maybe instead of fighting
her cancer so aggressively, we could have done more to make the end of her life
peaceful and less painful.
I didn’t
know it at the time, but I was experiencing my first real bout of moral
distress. It is broadly defined as a scenario when a healthcare professional
feels that they know the morally correct action to take to care for the
patient, but are restricted in some way from taking that action (more
on the topic of moral distress can be found here, if you’re interested.)
Now all
these years later, as I adjusted to working as a pediatrician in a very busy, very
high-acuity unit in a low resource setting, I began thinking about this case
again. Nearly every day, choices have to be made that bring back those unnerving
feelings of discomfort. They don’t all revolve around death, but all revolve
around struggling with knowing the right course of action, and not being able
to execute it properly. The child we send home who may need a few more
days of antibiotics, because there’s no more space in the unit and we need to
make room for the next sick child; the infant who goes days without getting the
correct antibiotic as the family scrounges together the few resources they have
to pay for it; the patient we can’t put on CPAP or oxygen because the only supply
available is being shared among several other patients at once. Moreover, when our
ability to test and find a cause for a patient’s illness, decision making can
become a lot harder (this is related to another type of moral distress related
to uncertainty.)
These are
challenges I was peripherally aware of during my time in U.S.; they came up
rarely, as most of my patients were healthy and resource allocation is not a
challenge you have to deal with often. My colleagues here have faced this every
day for years. They have incredible knowledge, perseverance and compassion, but
underneath the surface is a palpable frustration- a feeling of helplessness, of
uncertainty of what exactly needs to be done to tackle some of the systemic
challenges we face.
I started
writing this in the middle of the night, during a bout of insomnia, but initially
struggled to find a satisfactory conclusion, some enlightened wisdom to wrap this thing up in a neat little bow and end on a positive note. A few weeks is not enough time
to unpack things, to pick apart the machinery to find the pieces that are broken, and its certainly not enough time to know how to fix them. People who have lived and worked in this environment this every
day don’t have all the answers, so how on earth can a Western pediatrician with
a few weeks of working here have them in such a short time? I suppose the best I can do is use this
feeling of discomfort to keep trying, every day, piece by piece, to understand
the fabric, the strengths and the failures of the system here, and support in
whatever small ways I can. In the meantime, I suppose I’ll have to get used to
this strange discomfort- after all, everyone else here has been dealing with it
for years.
*name has
been changed.
No comments:
Post a Comment